What if a law designed to protect America's AI dominance actually handed the keys to its biggest rival? The proposed GAIN AI Act, while well-intentioned, threatens to undermine US leadership in artificial intelligence. By forcing US chipmakers to offer chips destined for China to domestic buyers first, the act creates market chaos that depresses prices and benefits foreign competitors. Vague rules about 'backlogs' also expose American companies to unpredictable penalties, crippling their ability to operate in a complex global supply chain. Ultimately, this legislation could accelerate China’s AI ambitions by ceding a massive market and pushing innovation overseas. Instead of restricting chip sales, a better strategy involves boosting clean energy for power-hungry AI and attracting top global talent to drive the next wave of innovation.